The Bad First Date: The Over-Sharer

július 12, 2026 Asteryn 8 min read
The Bad First Date: The Over-Sharer
About this story

Two people on a date where one person tells way too much personal info.

QUENTIN: I think it's important to be honest on first dates.
ELOWEN: I agree, but maybe not about everything, Quentin.
QUENTIN: For example, my childhood fear of balloons is real.
ELOWEN: That is... interesting, but a bit much for now.
QUENTIN: I once cried for three hours over a red balloon.
ELOWEN: Why are we talking about your crying, Quentin?
QUENTIN: Because vulnerability is the key to deep connection.
ELOWEN: Connection does not require a history of balloons.
QUENTIN: My mother says I have an "overflowing heart", Elowen.
ELOWEN: Your heart is overflowing into my personal space.
QUENTIN: I also have a very complicated relationship with cheese.
ELOWEN: What do you mean, a complicated relationship?
QUENTIN: I once tried to make a cheese fountain in my room.
ELOWEN: Why on earth would you do that, Quentin?
QUENTIN: I wanted to feel like a king of dairy, honestly.
ELOWEN: That sounds like a nightmare for the carpet, sir.
QUENTIN: It was! My landlord still hasn't forgiven me.
ELOWEN: Maybe we could talk about your actual job, Quentin.
QUENTIN: I work in insurance, but I secretly hate it.
ELOWEN: Most people don't love their jobs, that's normal.
QUENTIN: I spend my days dreaming of becoming a mime.
ELOWEN: A mime? You just told me you hate silence.
QUENTIN: Exactly! The irony is what makes it artistic, Elowen.
ELOWEN: I am not sure if I find this artistic or scary.
QUENTIN: Fear is just the soul's way of saying "hello".
ELOWEN: My soul is saying "get a cab and go home", sir.
QUENTIN: I can tell you about my collection of toenail clippings.
ELOWEN: WHAT? Why would you even mention that, Quentin?
QUENTIN: I keep them in labeled jars by the year, Elowen.
ELOWEN: That is the most disgusting thing I've ever heard.
QUENTIN: It's a record of my physical growth over time!
ELOWEN: I do not want to know about your nail growth, sir.
QUENTIN: You are just resisting the raw truth of biology.
ELOWEN: Biology should be kept in a medical lab, not jars.
QUENTIN: My jars are organized by alphabetical order of toe.
ELOWEN: There is no alphabetical order for toes, Quentin!
QUENTIN: I named them; the big one is "Albert".
ELOWEN: You named your toes? Please stop talking now.
QUENTIN: Albert was always the most stubborn of the bunch.
ELOWEN: This date is a disaster and I am in shock.
QUENTIN: Shock is just the body's way of processing truth.
ELOWEN: The truth is that you are a total weirdo, Quentin.
QUENTIN: Being a weirdo is my only real superpower, Elowen.
ELOWEN: Your superpower is making me want to leave immediately.
QUENTIN: I can also tell you about my recurring nightmare.
ELOWEN: NO! No nightmares! No more personal info!
QUENTIN: It involves a giant squid and a very small hat.
ELOWEN: Why are you still talking? I said stop, Quentin!
QUENTIN: The squid represents my fear of commitment, Elowen.
ELOWEN: My fear is now centered on your mental state, sir.
QUENTIN: Mental states are like weather; they always change.
ELOWEN: I hope the weather changes and you disappear.
QUENTIN: I once tried to live in a treehouse for a month.
ELOWEN: Why would you do that? Did you have a house?
QUENTIN: I did, but I wanted to be one with the squirrels.
ELOWEN: Squirrels are just rats with better tails, Quentin.
QUENTIN: That is a very harsh view of nature, Elowen.
ELOWEN: My view of this date is even harsher, honestly.
QUENTIN: Do you want to hear about my allergy to dust?
ELOWEN: I think I have an allergy to your conversation.
QUENTIN: My sneezes can be heard from three rooms away.
ELOWEN: I can imagine; you are very loud in general.
QUENTIN: Loudness is just a sign of a powerful presence.
ELOWEN: Your presence is currently overwhelming the table.
QUENTIN: I also have a very strange habit with salt.
ELOWEN: Please, for the love of god, do not tell me.
QUENTIN: I like to arrange it in small circles on my plate.
ELOWEN: Why? What does that achieve, Quentin?
QUENTIN: It creates a protective barrier against bad vibes.
ELOWEN: The only bad vibe here is this entire date, sir.
QUENTIN: Bad vibes are just opportunities for healing, Elowen.
ELOWEN: I will heal by leaving and never seeing you again.
QUENTIN: You can't leave yet; I haven't mentioned my ex.
ELOWEN: I am begging you, do not talk about your ex.
QUENTIN: She left me because I collected too many rocks.
ELOWEN: Oh, so you are a rock collector and a toe namer?
QUENTIN: I am a man of many diverse interests, Elowen.
ELOWEN: Your interests are a red flag the size of Texas.
QUENTIN: Red is a very passionate color, don't you think?
ELOWEN: It is the color of "stop" and "danger", Quentin.
QUENTIN: Danger is where the most excitement lives, truly.
ELOWEN: My excitement is for the bill to arrive, sir.
QUENTIN: I can tell you about my experience with hypnosis.
ELOWEN: No! Stop it! Just stop talking for one minute!
QUENTIN: The hypnotist made me believe I was a chicken.
ELOWEN: I believe you are a weirdo; that's enough truth.
QUENTIN: I clucked for three hours in a crowded mall, Elowen.
ELOWEN: This is a nightmare. I am living in a nightmare.
QUENTIN: Nightmares are just dreams with the volume turned up.
ELOWEN: My volume is now at maximum; I am leaving.
QUENTIN: Wait! I haven't told you about my toenail jars again!
ELOWEN: GOODBYE, Quentin! NEVER CALL ME AGAIN!
QUENTIN: She is definitely intrigued by my vulnerability.
ELOWEN: I am blocking him and moving to a different city.
The Bad First Date: The Over-Sharer
About this story

Two people on a date where one person tells way too much personal info.